Is it smart to fix your 7-year-old washing machine or buy new? Deep dive into costs, common problems, expert advice, and real stories.
Repair or Replace: Quick Guide to Deciding What to Do With a Faulty Appliance
When the washing machine starts rattling or the oven stops heating, the first question is always the same: should I repair it or buy a new one? It’s easy to feel stuck between a costly repair bill and the temptation of a shiny replacement. Below, we break down the key factors that help you choose the right path without overpaying or ending up with a half‑working unit.
Check Age and Warranty
Age is the simplest filter. Most appliances last 8‑12 years if they’re looked after. If yours is still under manufacturer warranty, a repair is usually free or cheap. Even if the warranty expired, many parts still have a 2‑year guarantee. So, pop open the manual or look up the purchase date online—if the unit is under 5 years, a repair often makes more sense financially.
Cost of Repair vs Replacement
Next, get a solid quote. A good rule of thumb is the 50 % rule: if the repair costs more than half the price of a comparable new model, start looking at replacements. For example, a £200 repair on a £350 dryer is a clear sign to replace. But if the fix is £80 on a £600 dishwasher, repairing is the smarter move.
Don’t forget hidden costs. Older appliances can be less energy‑efficient, meaning higher electricity or water bills. Factor those ongoing expenses into your decision. A slightly higher upfront price on a new, energy‑star model can pay back in lower utility bills within a few years.
Reliability and Frequency of Breakdowns
If an appliance has broken down more than once in the last two years, it’s probably screaming for a swap. Repeated fixes waste time and money, and they can damage other parts. One solid repair on a brand‑new unit is fine, but a pattern of failure signals it’s time to move on.
Also consider the part that’s failing. Replacing a heating element in an oven is usually straightforward and cheap. Swapping out a motor in a washing machine can be pricey and may affect other components. Understanding the complexity helps you gauge both cost and future reliability.
Environmental Impact
Repairing saves landfill space and reduces the demand for new raw materials. If you’re eco‑conscious, lean toward fixing whenever the cost and reliability checks are reasonable. Many local councils offer recycling programs for appliances you do decide to replace, so you won’t be stuck with waste.
When to Call a Pro
Some jobs are best left to certified technicians—think gas appliances, electric heaters, or any device with high‑voltage parts. A DIY fix on a boiler or a microwave can be dangerous and might void warranties. For those cases, get a qualified professional to assess the issue. Their advice often includes an honest repair‑vs‑replace recommendation.
Summing up, ask yourself four quick questions: How old is it? What’s the repair cost vs a new unit? How often does it break? And can I fix it safely? If the answers point toward a high‑cost, frequent‑failure scenario, replace. Otherwise, repair and enjoy a few more years of service.
Need a reliable local pro? South Shields Appliance Repair Services offers transparent quotes, fast turnarounds, and a guarantee on all work. Whether you’re fixing a dishwasher or deciding to upgrade, we’ll help you make the right call without hidden surprises.